It took the German conquest of France in June to substantially weaken the political power of the isolationists. By then, good outcomes were unobtainable. The United States was playing catch up from a bad position.
From that point, the bad choices Roosevelt faced at Yalta were nearly baked in. The United States might have tried to force a showdown with Stalin over Poland and Central Europe at an earlier phase of the war. The Tehran Summit in November was one such occasion. Instead, Washington stuck with a declaratory policy based on the Atlantic Charter rooted in Wilsonian principles, but without the power to make good on it.
Immediate victory over Germany took priority, and the United States was not willing to risk a showdown with Stalin over Poland. The United States hoped for the best and approached the Yalta Summit in February in that spirit. What did this mean? If Roosevelt were serious about applying the Atlantic Charter principles to Poland and Central Europe, why had he accepted such a weak commitment from Stalin at Yalta?
In dealing with Russian leaders, Roosevelt, like many US presidents after him, appeared to believe that gestures of good will and efforts to take account of legitimate Russian interests, would be enough to convince Russia to take a more tolerant approach to its neighbors.
Roosevelt seemed to hope that the momentum of wartime alliance, and the prospect of post-war entente and US support, would appeal to Stalin as much as it appealed to him. If so, Roosevelt would not be the last president to project his open mind to Russian leaders who did not share it. Roosevelt died on April 12, The Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action the Iran nuclear deal , though incomplete and flawed, was specific and enforceable.
Another is be realistic about relative strength, especially in the short term: in its World War Two aims, the United States allowed a gap to develop between its principles and power on the ground. The fates of hundreds of millions in Europe and Asia would rest on whatever agreement the Big Three reached at Yalta.
What, then, did their final settlement look like? It includes a statement by Churchill, Roosevelt, and Stalin on the results of the conference. In overall terms, Roosevelt, Churchill, and Stalin emphasize Allied unity, imminent victory, and commitment to human rights. There is no mention, for instance, of Allied plans in the Pacific Theater. At Yalta, Roosevelt and Churchill agreed to let Stalin annex parts of Japanese-held Manchuria in exchange for bringing his troops into the war against Japan.
Additionally, the Western Allies acceded to Soviet dominance of Eastern Europe and thus undermined their stated goal of installing free governments in Poland and elsewhere in the region. The Yalta press release is a prime example of an official document that obscures as much as it informs, and it thus captures the hope and uncertainty of the Allied governments in the last year of the war. Roosevelt upon arrival for Yalta Conference; Harry S. By March , it had become clear that Stalin had no intention of keeping his promises regarding political freedom in Poland.
Instead, Soviet troops helped squash any opposition to the provisional government based in Lublin, Poland. When elections were finally held in , they predictably solidified Poland as one of the first Soviet satellite states in Eastern Europe.
Many Americans criticized Roosevelt — who was seriously ill during the Yalta Conference and died just two months later, in April — for the concessions he made at Yalta regarding Soviet influence in Eastern Europe and Northeast Asia. But with his troops occupying much of Germany and Eastern Europe, Stalin was able to effectively ratify the concessions he won at Yalta, pressing his advantage over Truman and Churchill who was replaced mid-conference by Prime Minister Clement Atlee.
The Yalta Conference Office of the Historian, U. Department of State. But if you see something that doesn't look right, click here to contact us! Subscribe for fascinating stories connecting the past to the present.
The bombing was controversial because Dresden was neither important to German wartime production nor a major The Lend-Lease Act stated that the U. Nazi leader Adolf Hitler predicted a quick victory, but after initial success, the brutal campaign dragged on and eventually failed due to strategic blunders Stephens , to discuss the possibility of negotiating an end to the American Civil War, The instability created in Europe by the First World War set the stage for another international conflict—World War II—which broke out two decades later and would prove even more devastating.
0コメント